.

Accurate Info Lacking in Sandy Aftermath, JCP&L Told

Officials, residents raise concerns at third BPU hearing about utility company's storm response.

Nearly two months after Hurricane Sandy pummeled through the Northeast, the frustration about the communication from state officials and power companies in the storm aftermath is still a major discussion among members of the public.

The quality and accuracy of the information flow was the key subject brought up at the Board of Public Utilities third public hearing at Hopatcong Middle School Tuesday night.

More than 60 people, including local officials and residents from Morris, Sussex and Passaic counties, attended the meeting where over a dozen people commented and raised concerns to BPU and JCP&L officials about the state's preparedness and response after the storm that left millions across the state without power for days and some for weeks.

Several mayors said the power company provided false restoration numbers, which angered the residents in their municipalities in a time when they needed comfort most.

Hopatcong Mayor Sylvia Petillo told officials that residents wanted to get frequent updates on when the power was coming back, where crews were in town, and how many crews were working, but she couldn't receive any of that information from JCP&L. She added that the false restoration numbers, including the Sunday after the storm when a JCP&L representative , but were never restored, was a major issue.

She suggested having a JCP&L supervisor call the OEM director every morning to provide updates about the crews' daily work routines.

"Then we would have information to give out that would be current and it would be real," Petillo said. "Other than that we can not get the information from the managers that are assigned."

Frankford Mayor Gary Larson, who received an applause after he spoke, said the restoration charts given from the power company kept showing inaccuracies and added to the frustration during the outage.

"I don't understand why you would put those numbers up there," he told the officials. "We had residents coming in and asking us questions and there was very little we could give them."

Other residents who spoke agreed with officials, including Kim Armstrong, of Roxbury.

"I would ask the BPU to seriously consider appointing person to have that information in town so everyone is talking on same page," she said.

Hopatcong resident Carolyn Albanese suggested having JCP&L post updates on social media where crews are working in town, simliar to how she said the Hopatcong Police posted on their Facebook page whenever they saw crews on streets.

BPU president Robert Hanna said in his opening statements that the communication has been by far the biggest public complaint. He said while there were several methods of communication implemented after Hurricane Irene, including having more representatives in the town, greater use of social media, and creating the outage maps, he doesn't believe it was the forms of communication that was the problem, and instead the accuracy.

"The method is not the issue, he said. "There are plenty of methods in this day in age to get information. The problem really was the quality of information getting out there to the public. Many, many complaints of the information posted was inaccurate and incorrect information was given out."

He said while the utility companies can not generate street by street information, he said the companies "have to do a far better job in terms of the quality of information they provide to the public so that people at least can make an intelligent decision about whether they can stay in their homes or not."

JCP&L president Don Lynch said the power company is working to provide more accurate information regarding outages and restoration times.

"While no other utility in the country can currently do that down to the customer level, I am committed to work with the BPU to figure out how we can do that, how can we provide more specific information."

Lynch added that JCP&L is also currently working on a number of other steps to improve communication, including expanding communication channels in texting, emails and other alerts, and making enhancements to the power maps.

Lynch, who said the storm resulted in the largest restoration effort in the history of New Jersey, said nearly all JCP&L customers were effected by the storm with 1.3 million outages in all 236 municipalities.

"The damage that resulted from this storm was more damage than Hurricane Irene plus the snowstorm that hit us last October," he said.

Hanna said there were over 17,000 out-of-state workers that helped restore the power, which was the largest utility workforce ever mobilized in New Jersey.

He added that 71 percent of all New Jersey electrical distribution circuits were damaged from the storm. He said 116,000 trees came down, where over 64,000 of those were in JCP&L territory. There were over 6,700 JCP&L utility poles that came down as well, he said, which is the most of the four electrical companies in the state. 

"We are looking at all aspects of preparation and response by the electric utilities in the hopes that we can make this better," Hanna said.

Some of the other issues brought up Tuesday night in the two-and-a-half hour meeting were about the downed wires and trees that remained on the ground for days.

"The biggest issue that I had was that every major way in and out of this town, particularly Lakeside Bouelvard, remained block by downed trees for about a week," Hopatcong resident Andrew Dick said. "Please consider whether the town and county employees could be trained to work in areas where there are downed wires to safely secure wires to get roads open."

Hanna said all comments will be reviewed by state officials to improve the infrastructure.

"We will consider all comments in our proceedings in actions that we take," he said.

More meetings will be scheduled after the new year.

Residents can also submit written comments via email to: board.secretary@bpu.state.nj.us  or by mail to: Kristi Izzo, Secretary of the Board, Board of Public Utilities, 44 South Clinton Ave., 9th Floor, P.O. Box 350, Trenton, NJ 08625-0350.

The written comments should reference Docket Number EO12111050 in the subeject of the emails, or in the heading of a letter.

Frazure December 19, 2012 at 01:37 PM
Mr. Lynch stated -"nearly all JCP&L customers were effected by the storm with 1.3 million outages in all 236 municipalities". Hopefully, that's the number of municipalities JCP&L serves in NJ because there is a total of 566 municipalities in the state - you didn't "lose" a few towns, did you JCP&L? It has been revealed that much of the system and technology in place is antiquated and not up to current standards. Apparently, JCP&L chooses to reinvest little in it's aging infrastructure. Stop the "band-aid" approach - that's the first course of action the BPU should insist upon. Additionally, with power outages continually increasing in both frequency and duration causing horrendous inconvenience and disruption to its customers, I would like to see JCP&L offer a one time substantial subsidy to it's customers to put towards a temporary power generation system to help us limp by during these extended "black-outs".
SPky December 19, 2012 at 03:41 PM
Not to give the power company a free pass, but we should all take a look at the trees on our property and determine if they are a danger to our homes, power wires, and passing cars. Its expensive to cut trees down, but so was that 55" tv. I counted 15 homes struck by trees within a block of mine. Could that have been avoided or minimized with some personal responsibility?
Deborah Hanley December 19, 2012 at 03:57 PM
Seriously people... PUT IT BEHIND YOU!!! It was a disaster... AREN'T YOU EXPECTING A LITTLE TOO MUCH?!!! The electric companies are not God, they can only do what they can do. They did their best. It was not fun, but we SURVIVED! All of this concern... about NUMBERS?!!! THERE ARE BIGGER THINGS GOING ON IN THIS WORLD that you could be putting your attention to.
JM Mom December 19, 2012 at 04:51 PM
More than one person has told me that the power repair workers from out-of-state said that our infrastructure is so old that replacement parts are no longer available. First Energy has not put money into updating our antiquated infrastructure, and we pay the highest rates in the country.
JenniferB December 19, 2012 at 05:06 PM
I heard this a lot too.
Tracy Tobin December 19, 2012 at 05:59 PM
Mr. Hanna of the BPU (soon to be a judge) is incorrect. JCP&L put very little of the Post Irene recommendations into place. " HAVING MORE REPRESENTATIVES IN TOWN"? JCP&L was marked ABSENT in our town for days 10-14 of our power outages. The liaison to our town had 50 other towns to cover. Ridiculous in an emergency. The poor guy was probably lucky to get to read 10% of his e-mails from towns he was responsible for. JCP&L failed to provide adequate information to Out of State power restoral crews, which reduced their efficiency in repair efforts. Hazardous tree removal programs over the past year were "Too little Too Late" after 10 years of neglect. JCP&L's "pain" was self inflicted and transfered to it's customers. The BPU should not permit rate increases when JCP&L's neglect of their responsibilities was a major cause of outages. Why are so many power sub stations vulnerable to damage leading to wide spread outages? What did JCP&L learn from IRENE other than to blame Mother Nature for their failure to provide safe and secure infrastructure? The BPU better not try and sell "no one could have foreseen this storm" as a reason to reward JCP&L for their neglect of their responsibilities to their customers.
Steve December 19, 2012 at 07:09 PM
"He said while the utility companies can not generate street by street information, he said the companies "have to do a far better job in terms of the quality of information they provide to the public so that people at least can make an intelligent decision about whether they can stay in their homes or not." Why not? Use GPS and location based services with computer automation.
Julles51 December 19, 2012 at 07:43 PM
SPky - Sounds like a good idea...I actually tried that very thing. I had a tree service come by to give me an estimate on trimming the trees on my property that overhang the power lines. I was told that they won't touch any trees/limbs/branches hovering over the wires. I was told to call the power company. Now what to do?
Parsippany Taxpayer December 19, 2012 at 07:51 PM
Tracy hit the nail on the head while people like Deborah Hanley are part of the reason we are in this mess. Give them a pass for not doing their jobs of maintaining the lines, trimming back the trees and having proper worst case contingency plans. As corporate greed and maximizing shareholder wealth are their major concerns this type of situation is only going to get worst in the future. It is funny that Europe puts most of their lines underground and their power outage issues are minimal at best. Pays to do it right the first time but everyone here is so shortsighted by short term profits and forget about safety that we are decades behind Europe in our power infrastructure and don't even mention the roads.
Eileen Stokes December 19, 2012 at 08:40 PM
And I am wondering who is coordinating follow up on damaged poles and the transfer of ALL wires--electric, cable and phone--to the new poles? Past experience has shown me that this is another source of disconnect. Once one utility has transferred wires--usually the electric lines are first--the finishing process often falls between the cracks. I have on several past occasions contacted the various utilities to find out when work will be completed and the old broken pole removed. Am I the only one thinking that damaged poles continue to constitute a danger, especially as winter weather approaches? There are 4 or 5 damaged or unfinished utility transfer poles that I pass daily--one pole is completely severed into two pieces with all wires still attached and functioning, but stretched to their limit, another is split vertically with a new pole installed next to it and only electric transferred to the new pole. Is JCP&L responsible for follow up that the other utilities complete their portion of the work.
TCG December 19, 2012 at 09:07 PM
Whew! A meeting! Wow. Everyone feel better? Did I read this correctly? JCP&L is NOW going to get to work on better communication? Did anyone at the meeting bother to ask why that hadn't been done in the year between the two big storms? They are going to use email to inform people who don't have power? Brilliant. This is comical. Please...anyone...let us all know when these new policies have been implemented and how, exactly they will help. If the power company wanted to provide accurate information, they would. It's nice of them to apologize and claim they have to do better, but the question remains...a full year after the first big, destructive storm, what improvements did they make and why would they still be deliberately misleading residents? Of course the answer is meaningless because the all-powerful and totally unaccountable BPU decides what JCP&L does and what it doesn't do. And JCP&L knows it is under no threat whatsoever and will suffer not a single consequence for their actions...or lack thereof. By the way, did JCP&L pro-rate anyone's most recent bill to reflect the days and days without power? Just askin'....
Maryann Edwards December 19, 2012 at 11:39 PM
Yes, Mine was an estimated bill. I don't understand why they don't read our meters monthly like they used to do. We pay more and more money for less and less services. I am still waiting for the phone call to tell me that my power was restored. This company doesn't care about anything but profits. I was also told that our system is so antiquated that some of the out of state workers had never seen anything like it before. I also didn't see any JCP&L trucks working in my area, only out of state companies.
Roseanne Marie S. December 21, 2012 at 05:35 AM
Deborah you are right in saying there are bigger things going on in the world and I do think people have put it behind them. However I do think people are afraid of a repeat of the misinformation that ran rampant after the storm. If we don't learn from our mistakes we are doomed to repeat them. There was an instance of an elderly couple in another town choosing to stay in their home cause they believed JCP&L when they first told us power will be restored by Wednesday. As we all know, Wednesday turned into Sunday, and that elderly couple froze to death. I think we all need to look into getting another power company in here that is local. JCP&L had other states like Ohio, Virginia, and West Virginia to deal with first, as they made their way down to us. Like they said at one of the meetings, it is too expensive to maintain a crew in every state they service. So I think it's time we find someone who can.

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »